| South Central Conference All-Conference Team Members |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1996 |
| 1st Team Dusty Kallal - Center Nick Beilsmith - Running Back Terry Starks - Running Back Chris Brands - Linebacker Bob Seawright - Defensive Line Rob Marcopoulos - Defensive End 2nd Team Terry Starks - Defensive Back Jason Nash - Defensive Back Matt Kitzmiller - Quarterback Honorable Mention Dusty Kallal - Defensive End Bobby Flanigan - Offensive Line |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1995 |
| 1st Team Tim Pranger - Quarterback Dusty Kallal - Defensive End 2nd Team Steve Steward - Tight End Dennis Tucker - Guard/Linebacker Dusty Kallal - Center Nic Beilsmith - Running Back Terry Starks - Running Back Craig Pruiett - Defensive Back Honorable Mention Rob Marcopoulos - Defensive End Blake Ely - Linebacker Johnathan Wolff - Defensive Back |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1994 |
| 1st Team Jessie Stuckey - Punter 2nd Team Rob Macropoulos - Defensive End Honorable Mention Jared Childress - Offense/Defense Dennis Tucker - Defense Nick Beilsmith - Offense |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1979 |
| 1st Team Eldon Krause - Running Back Paul Lewis - Linebacker Gary St. Cin - Quarterback Honorable Mention Mike Burns - Offensive Tackle John Keller - Defensive Back |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1978 |
| 2nd Team Paul Lewis - Linebacker |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1984 |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1985 |
| Honorable Mention Gary Chapman |
| 1st Team Gary Chapman |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1975 |
| 2nd Team Tom Baker - Quarterback Bryan Kitzmiller - Defensive Back Honorable Mention Rocky Eveans - Running Back Dan Loy - Offensive Lineman |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1991 |
| Kent Prather Chad Bland Brian Werts |