| South Central Conference West Division All-Conference Team Members |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2002 |
| 1st Team Paul Lewis - Tight End Josh Reno - Running Back/Linebacker Aaron Bowman - Defensive Back Shawn Buchanan - Defensive Line Honorable Mention Shawn Buchanan - Guard |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2001 |
| 1st Team Luke Lahr - Tight End T.J. Huber - Tackle/Defensive Line Aaron Bowman - Defensive Back Honorable Mention Aaron Bowman - Wide Receiver Luke Lahr - Linebacker Josh Reno - Linebacker Nick Hanlon - Defensive Back |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2000 |
| Honorable Mention Dan Strohbeck - Wide Receiver/Defensive Back Sam Byndom - Running Back/Linebacker |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 1999 |
| 1st Team Jacob Smith - Guard Brandon Stephens - Quarterback Sam Powers - Tight End/Linebacker Sam Byndom - Defensive Line Jerad Pruitt - Defensive Back Honorable Mention Jarrod Walters - Running Back James Musgrave - Wide Receiver |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 1998 |
| 1st Team Sam Powers - Guard Neal Owens - Center/Linebacker Barry Brueggeman - Tackle/Defensive Line Jared Fryman - Tight End/Linebacker Neil Hanlon - Wide Receiver/Defensive Back Aaron DeLong - Running Back Nick Strohbeck - Quarterback David Taylor - Defensive Line Honorable Mention Nic Strohbeck - Defensive Back |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 1997 |
| 1st Team Barry Brueggeman - Tackle James Ward - Tackle Billy Timpe - Guard/Defensive Line Jason Darr - Center Aaron DeLong - Running Back Neal Owens - Defensive Line Chris Brands - Linebacker Jared Fryman - Linebacker Nic Strohbeck - Defensive Back Neil Hanlon - Defensive Back 2nd Team Jared Fryman - Tight End Chris Brands - Running Back James Ward - Defensive Line Barry Brueggeman - Defensive Line Jason Darr - Linebacker Aaron DeLong - Punter Matt Kitzmiller - Defensive Back Honorable Mention Matt Kitzmiller - Quarterback Kraig Reno - Linebacker |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2003 |
| 1st Team Tony Maronie - Tight End Josh Chism - Wide Receiver/ Defensive Back Bryce Baker - Linebacker Todd Cunningham - Punter |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2004 |
| 1st Team Jason Jackson - Offensive Line/Defensive Line Tony Maronie - Tight End Nick Albrecht - Wide Receiver/ Defensive Back Adam Stanton - Linebacker Bryce Baker - Linebacker Honorable Mention Adam Stanton - Running Back |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2005 |
| 1st Team Shane Nance - Offensive Line/Defensive Line Nick Albrecht - Wide Receiver/Defensive Back Gage Smith - Tight End/Linebacker Craig Bowman - Running Back Todd Cunningham - Punter |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2006 |
| 1st Team Brandon Avery - Tight End/Defensive Line Charlie Schwaab - Offensive Line Josh Savage - Running Back Zach Smith - Linebacker Dan Hagen - Wide Receiver Kyle Lincoln - Defensive Back Lucas Flannery - Defensive Line |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2007 |
| 1st Team Wiley Johnson - Offensive Lineman Jacob Gray - Tight End Jeremy Dunnagan - Wide Receiver Justin Miller - Defensive Line Ryan Cox - Defensive Back Honorable Mention Daniel Scott - Running Back Adam Wallace - Quarterback Michael Fisher - Linebacker |
| South Central West Division All-Conference Team 2008 |
| 1st Team Steven Bedell - Offensive Lineman Seth Rich - Tight End Brent Harrison - Running Back Zach Slightom - Wide Receiver Adam Wallace - Quarterback Nathan Kallal - Defensive Line Devin Hendricks - Linebacker Adam Wallace - Defensive Back Honorable Mention Conner Kessinger - Defensive Back |