| South Central Conference All-Conference Team Members |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1992-93 |
| 1st Team David Mills 2nd Team Adam Buhs Honorable Mention Todd Creal |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1991-92 |
| 1st Team Chad Bland 2nd Team Todd Creal |
| South Central Conference All-Conference Team 1994-95 |
| 1st Team Jerod Cottingham |
| SCC-West Conference All-Conference Team 2005-06 |
| 1st Team: Dace Hartman 2nd Team: Todd Cunningham Hon. Ment.: Chris Wood |
| SCC-West Conference All-Conference Team 2006-07 |
| 1st Team: Dace Hartman 1st Team: Dan Hagen 2nd Team: Keegan Darr |
| South Central Conference -West All-Conference Team 2000-01 |
| 2nd Team: James Musgrave 2nd Team: Cody Hanold |
| South Central Conference -West All-Conference Team 2001-02 |
| 1st Team: Daren Loy 2nd Team: Sam Woody H.M. Team: Eric Bowker H.M. Team: Aaron Bowman |
| 1st Team: Jacob Gray 2nd Team: Daniel Powell Hon. Ment.: Wiley Johnson |
| SCC-West Conference All-Conference Team 2007-08 |
| South Central Conference -West All-Conference Team 2003-04 |
| 1st Team: Michael Elliott 2nd Team: Brian Schaefer |